Scarlet Town Analysis – Part 3

Is it possible that Dylan is describing his hometown of Hibbing, Minnesota in this song? Perhaps I’m falling into the trap of assuming the lyrics of a song are necessarily autobiographical. Of course, that’s not always the case. However, I do think most everything an artist does is partly about themselves. It’s unavoidable.

There’s really nothing in the song that unequivocally states that the setting is Hibbing. I guess it’s just as likely that it’s no town in particular, just a general description of any small-town hometown USA. But still, let’s look around, see let’s see what we find.

the streets have names you can’t pronounce

https://minnesotasnewcountry.com/the-15-hardest-town-names-to-pronounce-in-minnesota/

The music starts and the people sway

Shuckling (also written as shokeling), from the Yiddish word meaning “to shake”, is the ritual swaying of worshippers during Jewish prayer, usually forward and back but also from side to side. (from Wikipedia)

Uncle Tom still workin’ for Uncle Bill

Typically your uncles live in your hometown, especially those that work together.

The song references – Set’em Up, Joe, Walking the Floor – are such that a person living in the 50’s in Hibbing would be familiar with them.

There are palm-leaf shadows and scattered flowers

That phrase doesn’t really help make my case.

In Scarlet Town, where I was born

He was born in Duluth. Close enough.

I touch the garment but the hem was torn

This reads to me like a rejection of his Jewish heritage, which of course for Dylan was rooted in Hibbing.

There’s walnut groves and maplewood

Both grow in Minnesota (and also in much of the USA).

Of course, only Dylan knows the answers to this, and he’s not saying. Does it really matter? Not really. But it could be Hibbing. Or not. It’s fun to consider.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

%d bloggers like this: